Hermina, Jakarta – The Supreme Court's (MA) appeal ruling in the case of gross human rights violations that occurred during the 2014 Paniai incident marks a new chapter in the handling of a tragedy that claimed the lives of civilians in Papua.
On November 10, through Case Number 12000 K/Pid.Sus-HAM/2026), the Supreme Court overturned an acquittal previously handed down by the Makassar Human Rights Court against retired Major Isak Sattu and declared that the defendant was guilty of the first and second charges. Sattu was sentenced to five years in prison.
The Supreme Court also mandated the payment of compensation to the victims, namely 250 million rupiah for those who died, 210 million rupiah for those who sustained severe injuries, 115 million rupiah for those with moderate injuries, and 75 million rupiah for those with minor injuries.
This ruling reverses the 2022 verdict by the Makassar Human Rights Court which had originally acquitted Sattu of all charges.
Do not stop at a single defendant
While welcoming the appeal ruling as an acknowledgment that gross human rights violations occurred during the 2014 Paniai incident, the 2014 Paniai Monitoring Coalition believes that the legal proceedings still leave serious issues unaddressed.
In a statement received on Friday November 13, the coalition, which comprises the Commission for Missing Persons and Victims of Violence (Kontras), the Democratic Alliance for Papua (ALDP), the Papua Human Rights Lawyers Association (PAHAM Papua), the Makassar Legal Aid Foundation (LBH Makassar), the Indonesian Institute for Independent Judiciary (LeIP), the Indonesian Legal Aid Foundation (YLBHI), Asian Justice and Rights (AJAR) and Amnesty International Indonesia (AII), urged law enforcement officials to investigate other individuals who may bear responsibility in the incident.
The coalition highlighted the prosecution's decision to bring only one defendant to trial, namely Isak Sattu, who, at the time of the incident served as the liaison officer for the 1705/Paniai Military District Command (Kodim) and held the highest rank among those coordinating the activities of the Military Sub-district Commands (Koramil) in the area.
According to the Coalition, a previous pro-justice investigation by the National Human Rights Commission (Komnas HAM) uncovered the alleged involvement of various parties within the chain of command, ranging from command policymakers, those in effective command on the ground, to the perpetrators in the field and those who allegedly allowed the abuses to occur through inaction.
The Coalition also highlighted the issue of potential obstruction of justice which was noted in the findings of the Komnas HAM investigation but was not included in the prosecutor's charges.
"The conviction of a single individual must not serve as grounds to close the door on uncovering the responsibility of other actors", stated the 2014 Paniai Monitoring Coalition on Friday.
Urging Attorney General to develop investigation
The Coalition is urging the Attorney General to follow up on the results of the Komnas HAM investigation by developing investigations into other parties suspected of being responsible for the 2014 Paniai Incident.
They asked that the legal process not stop with the verdict against Sattu, but continue to uncover the entire chain of responsibility.
The coalition also urged the government to fulfill victims' rights substantively. Recovery, according to the group, is not enough to just consist of compensation, but must include recovery for the physical, psychosocial and economic losses experienced by the victim and the victim's families.
In addition to this, the government was asked to immediately establish a Human Rights Court and a Truth Commission in Papua and continue handling allegations of other serious human rights violations, including the 2000 Abepura, 2001 Wasior and 2003 Wamena incidents.
Coalition highlights security approach in Papua
The coalition also asked the government, the Indonesian Military (TNI) and the National Police (Polri) to evaluate policies with a security approach which they said was still being implemented in Papua.
They believe that the resolution of the 2014 Paniai incident should be a momentum to reveal the truth as a whole and ensure state accountability towards the victims.
The court's appeal ruling, for the Coalition, is not the end of the process of seeking justice.
They emphasised that the resolution of the 2014 Paniai case must not stop at convicting one person, but must continue by uncovering all the actors suspected of being involved and ensuring the victims' rights to truth, justice and recovery. (release/odeodata h julia)
[Translated by James Balowski. The original title of the article was "Isak Sattu Dihukum 5 Tahun dalam Kasus Paniai, Koalisi Desak Aktor Lain Turut Diusut".]




